Well, you used test and copy, so I'd say that you ripped the CD a total of eight times, but since you used secure mode without C2, EAC actually asked the drive to read the disc a total of sixteen times.
Performing a wave comparison really helps to figure out what went wrong. There's nothing in the log files that points to anything obvious.
Do the CRCs change and/or become the same when ripping in burst mode or when enabling C2 pointers (if either of your drives can provide them)?